Bundled services or security as a single service? “Jury still out” states SRI study

The Security Research Initiative’s latest report is based on interviews with suppliers and procurers of security services looks at the benefits and drawbacks of providing security as a ‘single service’ or as part of a ‘bundle’ alongside other facilities management services.

Based on thorough studies undertaken by Perpetuity Research, the report identifies a range of drivers that determine success or failure in outsourcing arrangements. These include the:

• correct identification of the types of outsourcing that’s going to work best
• quality of the procurement process that’s used to help identify the best supplier(s)
• experience of the buyer in providing the type of sourcing chosen
• experience of suppliers (and/or in-house sources) to provide the required service to a high level
• extent to which this can be achieved cost effectively (not least compared to alternatives)

Professor Martin Gill speaking at the 2013 BSIA Annual Luncheon

Professor Martin Gill speaking at the 2013 BSIA Annual Luncheon

What clients say about approaches to security procurement

Clients involved in the research process stated that they outsource their security for reasons that include:

• security companies being experts at security
• the fact that it’s more cost-effective

Clients surveyed also said they prefer to keep security in-house for reasons that include:

• security contractors are not sufficiently competent
• they don’t possess expertise in sub-contracting work

Clients like bundling because:

• they feel it offers cost savings and financial flexibility
• it affords an opportunity to standardise practices and improve management practices

Those clients who were questioned as part of the research also choose not to bundle for reasons that include:

• a feeling that bundling security with other services could lead to security being undermined
• a feeling that bundling security leads to a loss of control when it comes to the security function

What suppliers say about approaches to security procurement

Suppliers who took part in the survey feel that bundling is a good option because:

• it reduces administration for clients (this can result in cost savings)
• it can raise the quality of work of weaker parts of a bundle and allow staff to become more engaged with the wider organisation

Suppliers believe single service security is a good option because:

• it allows the client to choose the ‘Best in Class’ option
• managing single services can be more straightforward than complicated bundles

Professor Martin Gill, director of Perpetuity and the leader of this study, commented: “The jury is still out on whether the popularity of bundling in some places is a sign of new and better ways of working or a cyclical change brought about because, in current times, cost is often a priority over risk. There were strong supporters of some of the benefits of single service and some of bundling, although not always on a strong evidence base. What this study has shown is that many organisations have an incomplete understanding of the benefits and drawbacks of providing security in different ways.”

Background to the research

The research is based on in-depth telephone and face-to-face interviews with 44 clients and 28 suppliers of security services from a range of countries. The interviews were carried out in the first quarter of 2013. This was supplemented by an online survey of 145 clients and suppliers.

The research was undertaken by Perpetuity Research (which started life as a spin-out from the University of Leicester) under the umbrella of the Security Research Initiative (http://www.perpetuityresearch.com/sri.html), which itself conducts a study each year into a chosen aspect of security.

To download a free copy of the full report please go to http://www.perpetuityresearch.com/main.php or e-mail: prci@perpetuityresearch.com for more details.

Alternatively, telephone: 0116-222 5553.

Leave a comment

Filed under IFSECGlobal.com News

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s